American Civil War Surgical Antiques

Research - Identification - Consultations

Civil War Era Surgical Kits, Surgeon's Swords & Images

Civil War Surgical & Medical Books

Established 1995

 

  Surgery Set Evaluations |  Main page  |  Search  |  Site map

 Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Pre & Post Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Topic Indexes  |  Contact Dr. Echols

 Medical Lecture Cards | Reference Books  |  Civil War Medical Books  | Surgeon Images & Swords  

 

Wanted to Buy List

Pre-1865: Surgery Sets, Medical Textbooks, Medical College Lecture Cards

The Private Collections of

Dr. Michael Echols

Evaluations & Consultations

Provided at No-Charge for Pre-1865 Surgery Sets, Instruments, Medical Textbooks

 

Dr. A. B. Beattie's Presentation Sword

 The collection of  Paul R. Johnson, M.D., F.A.C.S.

Contact for Dr. Paul Johnson regarding swords and images

M 1840 Medical Staff sword inscribed to Dr. A. B. Beattie, 49th Illinois Infantry.  Dr. Beattie was commissioned in Illinois and served with his regiment thru late 1862.  He saw action and cared for his regiment's wounded at the battle of Ft. Donelson (where the Colonel was a casualty), the battle of Shiloh/Pittsburg Landing (where both the Lt. Colonel and Major were casualties), and at Corinth.  It is presumed that he resigned due to illness after Shiloh (late in 1862), but current research is still underway.

The sword is an imported European piece without any manufacturer's markings.  The style is very similar to the Tiffany presentation sword (first sword in display-Dr. John Dwyer) in the hilt eagle and MS/shield motif, as well as the Gunkle sword (10th sword in display).  In addition, the middle scabbard fitting (lowest hangar) appears nearly identical to Bunce's sword (13th in display).

This sword is one of two which demonstrate presentation inscription on the SIDE of the hilt, rather than on the reverse shield or on the scabbard or it's fittings.  Indeed, the other know sword similarly inscribed is also on an European import sword to another Illinois Surgeon, which raises the very interesting possibility of similar engraver, sword outfitter, or military goods dealer in a similar Illinois town or area?

This sword shows another very rare aspect:   only "Medical Staff" is etched on the blade, rather than the usual 'U.S. Medical Staff'.  This sword overall is very dainty and smaller than the usual Ames or Horstmann specimens and is overall very similary to the Gunkle and Dwyer swords (# 10 and #1).

 

M 1840 Medical Staff sword inscribed to Dr. A. B. Beattie, 49th Illinois Infantry. 

 

Closer view of Beattie's M 1840 sword and scabbard

Closer view of the hilt detail of the Beattie inscribed sword.  The eagle and silver MS are very similar to the Tiffany/Dwyer sword (#1), and the Gunkle sword (#10).  The hilt itself is a bit more bulbous/round than the more slender Ames and Horstmann examples on this display

View of the blade of the Beattie sword showing that only:  "Medical Staff" is etched, rather than the usual  'U.S. Medical Staff'.

This would appear to be a very, very  rare variation.  No other obvious medical themes are etched.  No manufacturer's markings are noted on the blade or tang.

 

View of Beattie's sword's scabbard/hangar fitting with it's elaborate design which is nearly identical to Bunce's sword (#13), which is also an European import, manufactured by Klingenthal. 

View of the inscription on the SIDE of the hilt which notes:  "Dr. A. B. Beattie".  Similar to one other 105th Illinois Surgeon's inscription on another European imported M 1840 Medical Staff sword.

Opposite side of hilt inscription:  "Red Bud, Ill

 

 

 Main page  |  Search  |  Site map

 Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Pre & Post Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Topic Indexes  |  Contact Dr. Echols

Medical Lecture Cards | Reference Books  |  Civil War Medical Books  | Surgeon Images & Swords  

 

 

American Civil War Surgical Antiques 

Research notes and a private collection

 Pre-1865 Civilian & Civil War Military Surgical Antiques

This site contains the personal notes and collection of private collector Michael Echols.  Dr. Echols is not a dealer and nothing on this site is for sale.   All content 'by Dr. Echols' and all photography on this Web Site is copyrighted 1995 - 2008 and may not be used on any other web site or in print without the expressed e-mail permission from Dr. Echols:  Contact   All rights reserved.  Information gladly provided to dealers, authors, magazines, archivists, museums, and researchers.  Please reference and link this website to any on-line or printed use.

   Students and teachers are welcome to use the content on this educational site for reports or projects without permission.  All others please request permission first as everything on the site written or produced by Dr. Echols is copyrighted and all rights are reserved.  Thank you!

Links to this site are welcomed

 

Site last updated: Friday, May 09, 2008