American Civil War Surgical Antiques

Research - Identification

Civil War Era Surgical Sets, Surgeon's Swords & Images

Civil War Surgeon Education & Medical Books

Established 1995

 

  Surgery Set Evaluations |  Main page  |  Search  |  Site map

 Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Pre & Post Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Topic Indexes  |  Contact Dr. Echols

 Medical Lecture Cards | Reference Books  |  Civil War Medical Books  | Surgeon Images & Swords  

 

Wanted to Buy List

The Private Collections of

Dr. Michael Echols

Evaluations & Consultations

 

A  Comparison of 1850's and 1860's Gemrig Surgical Set

By Michael Echols

Comparing similar sets which are close in age can be a very learning experience.  Examining these two sets which were made on either side of the Civil War is very interesting to see the similarities and differences.

The knives are about the same size and design in both eras, however the handles are heavier on the earlier 1850's set and thinner on the later 1860's set.  

The 1860's capital and metacarpal saws are smaller in size than the earlier versions from the late 1850's.  

Note the variation in the tourniquets, the earlier type has a heavy brass frame buckle, the later one does not have that feature.  The bone forceps are very different as are the blades and handles of the capital saws.

See an 1866 Gemrig catalog with diagrams of instruments.

Links to additional photos 1860's set   1850's set

1860's Gemrig

 1850's Gemrig

1860's Gemrig

lift out tray

mvc-233s.jpg (33709 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

lift out tray

1860's Gemrig 

16 1/4 x 6 3/4 x 3 1/8

mvc-234s.jpg (19305 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

16 3/4 x 7 1/4 x 3

1860's Gemrig 

knife handle is lighter and thinner

mvc-240s.jpg (16563 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

knife handle is heavier and thicker

1860's Gemrig 

metacarpal saw is smaller

mvc-241s.jpg (18653 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

metacarpal saw is larger

1860's Gemrig 

capital saw is smaller 

mvc-237s.jpg (29901 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

capital saw is larger with slots

1860's Gemrig 

later smoother handle design

mvc-238s.jpg (24106 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

earlier more ornate 'English' style design

1860's Gemrig

tourniquet with no brass buckle blued prongs

mvc-235s.jpg (29915 bytes)

1850's Gemrig 

tourniquet with brass buckle brass prongs

1860's Gemrig

later and larger Liston style bone forceps

mvc-239s.jpg (22382 bytes)

1850's Gemrig

earlier and smaller Satterlee's bone forceps

 

 

 

 Main page  |  Search  |  Site map

 Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Pre & Post Civil War Surgery Set Displays  |  Topic Indexes  |  Contact Dr. Echols

Medical Lecture Cards | Reference Books  |  Civil War Medical Books  | Surgeon Images & Swords  

 

 

American Civil War Surgical Antiques 

Research notes and a private collection

 Pre-1865 Civilian & Civil War Military Surgical Antiques

This site contains the personal notes and collection of private collector Michael Echols.  Dr. Echols is not a dealer and nothing on this site is for sale.   All content 'by Dr. Echols' and all photography on this Web Site is copyrighted 1995 - 2008 and may not be used on any other web site or in print without the expressed e-mail permission from Dr. Echols:  Contact   All rights reserved.  Information gladly provided to dealers, authors, magazines, archivists, museums, and researchers.  Please reference and link this website to any on-line or printed use.

   Students and teachers are welcome to use the content on this educational site for reports or projects without permission.  All others please request permission first as everything on the site written or produced by Dr. Echols is copyrighted and all rights are reserved.  Thank you!

Links to this site are welcomed

 

Site last updated: Sunday, July 13, 2008